Former Real Madrid coach Jorge Valdano has launched a robust defense of Kylian Mbappe, asserting that the intense criticism directed at the French superstar amounts to 'abuse'. Valdano firmly believes that Mbappe stands as the undisputed best player in the world today, a conviction bolstered by his past World Cup triumphs and his consistent, prolific goal-scoring record.
Valdano contends that the public discourse surrounding Mbappe has devolved into a toxic environment. He argues that the player is unfairly burdened with blame, facing scrutiny for both Paris Saint-Germain's shortcomings and, paradoxically, Real Madrid's own struggles. This narrative, according to Valdano, is not only unwarranted but also damaging to the player's reputation.
The former coach pointed to Mbappe's impressive scoring figures, noting that he is currently the top scorer in La Liga. This statistical evidence, Valdano suggests, makes the relentless scrutiny and harsh judgments appear less like legitimate critique and more akin to mistreatment. The disparity between his on-field performance and the negative commentary is a key point in Valdano's argument.
This strong backing for Mbappe from Valdano aligns with sentiments previously expressed by Real Madrid president Florentino Perez. Perez had also publicly referred to Mbappe as the club's 'best player', even amidst a season where the team failed to secure any major trophies. This indicates a consistent belief in Mbappe's individual brilliance within the club's hierarchy.
Despite the collective challenges faced by the team during the 2025-26 season, Mbappe managed to secure the prestigious Pichichi Trophy. This award, recognizing him as the league's top scorer with 25 goals, marks a significant individual achievement. Furthermore, it establishes a remarkable precedent, making him the first Real Madrid player since the legendary Cristiano Ronaldo to clinch this honor in consecutive seasons.
Valdano's defense underscores the perception that Mbappe, despite playing for a team that has faced difficulties, remains an individual talent of the highest caliber. The 'abuse' label suggests that the pressure and criticism he endures are disproportionate to his contributions and talent, painting him as a scapegoat rather than a celebrated asset.
The comparison to Cristiano Ronaldo further emphasizes the historical significance of Mbappe's achievement. Winning the Pichichi Trophy in consecutive seasons is a testament to sustained excellence, a feat only accomplished by one of Real Madrid's greatest ever forwards. This highlights Mbappe's place among the elite.
Ultimately, Valdano's intervention aims to reframe the narrative around Kylian Mbappe, moving the focus from perceived team failures to his undeniable individual brilliance. By labeling the criticism as 'abuse', he is calling for a more balanced and fair assessment of a player who, by many metrics, continues to perform at the very highest level of the sport.
